How Long Are Crumbl Cookies Good For?

It cannot be denied how famous and popularly eaten Crumbl cookies are, both by young adults and kids. The love for these cookies grows further, especially because of their iconic pink packaging. However, we may have too much for one day and may decide to keep the rest for later devouring. 

Do you wonder how long you can store crumbl cookies? And how long are stored Crumbl cookies good for? 

When stored properly Crumbl cookies can last 4-5 days in an airtight container at room temperature. Also, they can be frozen at 110 degrees for several days. It is advisable to ensure they are completely cool before storing and freezing them and cleanly doing so in an airtight container. 

Crumbl cookies is a faster-growing cookie brand that is family oriented, we love to eat them because of their amazing chewy goodness and sometimes like to store them to eat later. Let’s discuss how long Crumbl cookies are good for and how to store them. 

How Long Should Crumbl Cookies Be Stored For?

Crumbl cookies are a popularly known cookie brand, with over 300 bakeries in 36 states nationwide. They are also branded with great customer reviews, because of the amazing cookie quality they produce, their packaging,  and customer service. 

However, after ordering a party box and you can only eat up a substantial amount, you’re left to wonder how to freshly store your leftover Crumbl cookies to eat at a later time. The Crumbl company has formally stated that you can freshly store your cookies for up to 5 days.

You can do so by ensuring you allow them to cool (if you bought the warm crumbl cookies option) and neatly place them into the airtight container at room temperature. 

There’s also the option of refrigeration, this is best because it keeps your cookies cool for a longer period. It is worthy to note that not all types of crumbl cookies should be frozen. One should be careful about freezing cookies with non-traditional frosting like Passion fruit, Key lime pie, Boston cream pie, Berries, and cream, etc. 

Also, be cautious not to freeze cookies with toppings that may become mushy for so long. Cookies such as Peanut Butter cookies ft Muddy Buddies, and the Cinnamon cookie ft Cinnamon Toast Crunch. 

How To Bake Cookies Without Parchment Paper
Image: Envato Elements

Do Crumbl Cookies Need to Be Refrigerated 

We all love when our favorite meals or snacks can be freshly kept and stored for a longer period, to allow us to store them in bulk and enjoy them for a longer time frame.

Refrigeration helps to offer this, as you can store meals for longer without having to worry about temperature problems or the food going bad. 

Furthermore, let’s discuss how to freeze and thaw unfrosted and frosted crumbl cookies; 

How To Freeze And Thaw Unfrosted Crumbl Cookies 

Some popular crumbl frosted cookies include; Milk chocolate chip, Original ft M&M’s, Blueberry Muffin, Brownie Batter, Classic Oatmeal, etc.

1. How to Freeze Them

Start by ensuring these cookies are completely cool before trying to freeze them. The next step is to ensure these cookies don’t stick when freezing them. You can avoid this by wrapping each cookie separately in plastic wrap or you cut squares of parchment/ wax paper and place them between each cookie and then stack them. 

Then you’re ready to pack the cookies into freezer-safe bags, freezer-safe reusable containers, or the usual zip-top bag. Layer the cookies into your preferred back and label them to remember when you started freezing the cookie setting. They can be frozen for up to 1 month. 

2. The Thawing Process

You can easily thaw frozen frosted crumbl cookies, by removing the cookie from the freezer container and thawing at room temperature until it’s soft and ready to eat. Only thaw the cookie ration you can eat, as re-freezing is not advised. 

How To Freeze And Thaw Frosted Crumbl Cookies 

Frosted cookies with basic buttercream or with similar frosting ought to freeze well, cookies like Confetti cake, Cookies, and cream milkshake, Peanut butter cookies ft snickers, will freeze well. 

1. How to Freeze

Start by freezing frosted cookies prior to placing them into freezer-safe containers, this helps the frosting remain intact. Once frozen (for about 1-2hours) wrap each set into parchment paper and stack (two cookie set max) in a freezer-safe container of choice.

Label with the date of freezing and keep for up to 1 month. 

2. How to Thaw

To avoid soggy frosted cookies, you can use a fresh freezer-safe bag to thaw your cookies, instead allow thawing in the fridge and not at room temperature until ready to eat. This is for food safety purposes. 

Final Thoughts 

Crumbl cookies is a vastly popular and enjoyed cookie brand, that’s left its customers satisfied and coming back for more.

If you’ve had enough cookie goodness for one day and you need to store them, you can easily do so by keeping them in an airtight container and storing them at room temperature for up to 5 days.

However, for a longer storage time frame, you can opt to freeze them by covering them in parchment paper and storing them in freezer-safe bags, for up to 1 month.