Can You Put Uncrustables In The Toaster?

Do you probably have some uncrustables laying in your freezer, and you’re wondering if you can reheat this product in the microwave? As pastries are better warm or steaming, do you want to heat your Uncrustables sandwich and you want to try heating it in the toaster

The Smucker Uncrustables are a popular fast food invention, healthy for adults and kids. Are you looking for a quick method to reheat this sandwich?

According to the manufacturer of uncrustables, it is officially stated not to prepare uncrustables using a toaster or air fryer. However, seeing as microwaves are also not an advisable method for re-heating uncrustables. Many people have been able to successfully heat uncrustables using a toaster. 

The hack is to try heating uncrustables for 3.5/4 minutes on a toaster, this way it’ll be a little frozen in the middle while being warm and crispy on the outside. This way uncrustables can be enjoyed heated. 

This short write would highlight and discuss if it’s safe to put uncrushable in the toaster, and how to safely heat uncrustables in the toaster.

New In This Series:

Is It Safe To Heat Uncrustables In The Toaster?

We are probably wondering why it is manufacturer recommended unsafe to heat uncrustables using a microwave or a toaster; there are some delicate reasons for this effect.

Firstly, uncrustables are stuffed with delicate fillings, that can burst out or become extremely hot when directly heated in the microwave or toaster. This can either make the sandwich look messy or charred to eat or cause burns to your mouth and throat when eaten. 

Secondly, when heating uncrustables with their packaging, can cause the plastic packaging to melt into the sandwich. This way harmful chemicals leach onto the fast-food pastry making it unsafe to eat. 

Thirdly, the direct radio heat from the microwave or toaster can char or burn the outside of the sandwich, making it unappetizing to eat. 

Can You Put Uncrustables In The Toaster?

Lastly, it is officially stated by the manufacturers of Smucker Uncrustables, that “it is not recommended to prepare uncrustables in the microwave, toaster or air fryer”. 

Although all these reasons are mentioned above to guide, you are to practice safe heating of uncrustables healthily by using a stovetop or skillet. Many uncrustables consumers have found a simple hack of being able to still heat the dish using a toaster. 

We are pro safety and advise you to always prepare a dish using the right and safe test means possible, however, if you’re in a hurry and in need of an uncrustables sandwich, here is how to prepare it on the toaster and the stovetop as well.

Can You Put Uncrustables In The Air Fryer?

Yes, you can put uncrustables in the air fryer and have it cook to perfection. Air fryer uncrustables turn out just as great as cooking them in the microwave and in addition, the result is a golden brown crispy brown outside and a delicious hot filling on the insides. Uncrustables are easier to make in an air fryer.

To make these treats in the air fryer, have them removed from all the packaging and put straight into the air fryer basket. You can spray the sides lightly with butter then cook at 390 degrees for 4 minutes.

How To Safely Toast Uncrustables

The Smucker Uncrustables can be toasted in two different ways, you can either heat it in the toaster or on the stovetop. 

1. The Toaster Method 

The toasting method is short and easy to follow, allow your uncrustables to thaw for some time, then simply pop the sandwich in the toaster for about 3-4 minutes with you monitor the process. 

Tip: Keep an eye on the toasting process, so your sandwich doesn’t get too dark unless it’s your preference. 

2. The Stovetop Method

The stovetop gives a better crispy and warm effect to your uncrustables sandwich, you can simply do this by allowing your sandwich to thaw for some time, then heat butter or oil in a pan over medium heat.

Then, place the sandwich facing crust-side down, and cook for about 2 minutes on each side, or until the bread looks golden brown.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do uncrustables say do not microwave? 

This is because they are designed to be delicious on-the-go snacks, with no preparation required. Additionally, the filling has the potential to get very hot when microwaved.

Do you thaw uncrustables before frying? 

Yes, do not oil fry frozen uncrustables because the outsides will be ready before the insides are thawed and heated. 

How do you cook Smucker’s Uncrustables?

The best method to safely cook frozen Smucker Uncrustables and achieve their gold-brown crispness is to heat your sandwich on the stovetop for about 2 minutes per side.

Final Thoughts 

Voila! you’ve come to the end of this short article, although Smucker Uncrustables have advised their consumers not to microwave, toast or air fry their produced sandwich for safety reasons.

Many people on personal experience have been able to successfully heat uncrustables in the toaster and enjoy its crispness 

If you’re on the side of caution, then it is best to heat your uncrustables on the stovetop and enjoy the best golden brown crispness, uncrustables have to offer. In the end, whichever method you try out, we would love to hear how it turned out.